Skip to Content

Is a hand press juicer better than a juicer?

Juicing has become an increasingly popular way to get more nutrients from fruits and vegetables. Using a juicer allows you to extract the juice from produce, leaving behind the fiber. This results in a concentrated, nutritious beverage that is easy to consume. There are two main types of juicers to consider – electric juicers and hand press juicers. So which type of juicer is better?

How Hand Press Juicers Work

A hand press juicer, also known as a manual juicer, works by squeezing or pressing the juice out of fruits and veggies. Here’s how it works:

  1. Cut the produce into small chunks that will fit into the juicer.
  2. Place the pieces of fruit or veggies inside the basket of the juicer.
  3. Use the lever to lower the press onto the produce, squeezing it against a strainer.
  4. The juice flows through tiny holes in the strainer and into a collecting container.
  5. The dry pulp is left behind in the basket.

Hand press juicers are operated entirely by manual force. You provide the power by lowering the lever press. They are compact, lightweight, and typically inexpensive compared to electric juicers.

How Electric Juicers Work

Electric juicers use a motor to spin produce at high speeds in order to separate the juice from the pulp. There are a few different types of electric juicers:

  • Centrifugal juicers: These have a grate basket and spinning blade. Produce is shredded against the grate, then spun forcefully to separate juice from pulp via centrifugal force.
  • Masticating juicers: Also called cold press or slow juicers. They crush and press produce through a spiral auger at slow speeds.
  • Triturating juicers: The most high-powered and efficient electric models. They have twin augers that effectively extract juice from produce.

Electric juicers require an external power source, but are very fast and efficient compared to manual juicing. They come in a range of sizes and prices.

Factors to Compare

Here are some key factors to consider when deciding between a hand press juicer and an electric juicer:

Juice Yield

Electric juicers extract more juice from produce. Centrifugal models can spin produce at up to 14,000 RPM, maximizing juice yields. Masticating and triturating juicers also have very high juice yields.

Hand press juicers rely solely on your strength to press out the juice. You may need to press multiple times to get out all the juice. The juice yields will be lower compared to electric models.

Juice Quality

Juice quality refers to how much of the vitamins, minerals, and nutrients are retained. Electric masticating and triturating juicers produce high-quality juice. The slow crushing and pressing keeps the juice cooler and better preserves nutrients.

Centrifugal juicers can damage nutrients due to high-speed shredding and the juice heating up. Hand press juicers also retain more nutrients since the juice remains cooler.

Speed and Convenience

Electric juicers are undoubtedly much faster. Centrifugal models can produce a glass of juice in mere seconds. Even slow juicers are faster than hand pressing.

Hand press juicers require much more physical effort and time to make juice. You also have to chop produce into small pieces before juicing. Clean up can also be more inconvenient compared to some electric models.

Versatility

Most electric juicers can handle all types of common produce like fruits, leafy greens, carrots, etc. Some masticating and triturating juicers can also make nut milks and grind coffee.

Hand press juicers may struggle with harder or fibrous produce. You’ll get the best results from soft, watery fruits and vegetables.

Cost

Juicer Type Typical Cost
Hand press juicer $20 – $50
Centrifugal juicer $50 – $200
Masticating juicer $200 – $400
Triturating juicer $400 – $500+

Hand press juicers are the most affordable option. Electric juicers range widely in price depending on the type and features. Higher priced electric models typically have more power and better performance.

Hand Press Juicer Pros and Cons

Pros:

  • Inexpensive
  • Compact and portable
  • Easy to clean
  • Retains nutrients well
  • Quiet operation

Cons:

  • Lower juice yields
  • Can be tiring and time consuming to use
  • Limited to soft, watery produce
  • More prep work needed
  • Pulp can get stuck and clog the strainer

Electric Juicer Pros and Cons

Pros:

  • Very fast juicing
  • Higher juice yields
  • Can juice all types of produce
  • More versatility with some models
  • Less physical effort required

Cons:

  • Can be noisy
  • More expensive
  • Larger countertop footprint
  • More parts to clean
  • Some nutrient loss, especially with centrifugal models

Which Type is Best?

There is no definitive “best” type of juicer that fits everyone’s needs. Here are a few key considerations in deciding between hand press and electric juicers:

  • Your budget – Hand press juicers are far less costly.
  • Types of produce – Electric juicers can handle all produce; hand presses do best with soft fruits and veggies.
  • Juicing frequency – Frequent juicers will benefit from the speed of electric models.
  • Nutrient retention – Hand presses and slow electric juicers preserve nutrients best.
  • Juice yield – Electric juicers extract substantially more juice.

For occasional juicing or small batches, a hand press juicer may meet your needs. If you plan to juice often, have a variety of produce, and want high yields, an electric juicer is likely the better choice.

Conclusion

Hand press juicers provide an affordable and compact option for making fresh, healthy juice at home. They retain nutrients well but require more physical effort. Electric juicers make juicing fast and efficient, but come at a higher cost. Consider how often you plan to juice, your budget, and types of produce to determine which juicer best fits your lifestyle.

Focusing on easy to juice produce like citrus fruits, berries, tomatoes, and cucumbers can help maximize the performance of a hand press juicer. Soft fruits and veggies with high water content are best. If you want to juice leafy greens, carrots, or hard root vegetables, an electric model is likely a better choice.

Look for a hand press juicer with a sturdy metal construction that feels solid when leveraged. Metal strainers are also preferable over plastic options. Easy disassembly makes cleaning quicker after each use. Within the range of electric juicers, masticating and triturating models produce the highest quality, most nutrient-dense juices.

Whichever type of juicer you choose, making fresh juice at home is a great way to incorporate more fruits and vegetables into your diet. Drink juice straight or use it to make healthy smoothies, ice pops, and other recipes. Both hand press and electric juicers have their advantages depending on your needs.