Is a milkshake just milk and ice cream?

One of the most beloved drinks in the United States is undoubtedly the milkshake. As Americans, we tend to think of milkshakes as a mixture of ice cream and milk, but is that really the case? In this blog post, we will explore the history of milkshakes, the recipes of milkshakes, and the ingredients that go into making this delightful treat.

The History of Milkshakes

Believe it or not, milkshakes didn’t always contain ice cream. According to historians, milkshakes were originally served as alcoholic beverages in the late 1800s. Patrons could order a “whiskey milkshake” or a “brandy milkshake” at cafes, making them a popular drink among adults.

Over time, milkshakes transitioned into non-alcoholic drinks and became popular among children and teenagers. In the early 1900s, drug store soda fountains became a hub for milkshakes. Pharmacists would mix the drinks and add ingredients like chocolate, caramel, and fruit syrups to create new and exciting flavors.

In the 1920s, the addition of ice cream to milkshakes became popular, making the beverage thicker and creamier. With the use of the soda fountain, milkshakes could be made quickly in large quantities, becoming a go-to drink for those on the go.

The Recipes of Milkshakes

Milkshakes are a simple beverage that can be made with a variety of ingredients. The classic milkshake consists of milk, ice cream, and a flavoring syrup. However, it’s not unusual to find additional ingredients like fresh fruit, candy, or cookies added to make unique variations.

One popular type of milkshake is the malted milkshake. Malted milk powder is added to the drink, giving it a slightly nutty flavor and a thicker consistency. Another popular type of milkshake is the “adult” milkshake, which includes alcohol like vodka, bourbon, or rum in the recipe.

The Ingredients That Go Into Making A Milkshake

Now let’s get to the heart of the question: is a milkshake just milk and ice cream? The answer is no. While milk and ice cream are essential ingredients in a milkshake, there are typically other ingredients added to create different flavors and textures.

For example, chocolate syrup can be added to create a chocolate milkshake, or fresh fruit like strawberries can be blended in to create a strawberry milkshake. Some recipes may even call for whipped cream or cookies to be added to the top of the shake as a garnish.


In conclusion, milkshakes are a delicious treat that has been around for many years. While the standard recipe for a milkshake may contain milk and ice cream, there are numerous variations that can be created by adding flavors, toppings, or even alcohol. The next time you order a milkshake, don’t be afraid to try something new and unique! And remember, a milkshake is never just milk and ice cream.


Do you have to have milk in a milkshake?

Milkshakes are a delicious treat enjoyed by many people around the world. They are a popular drink that can be found in almost any ice cream shop, fast food restaurant, or diner. While most milkshakes are made with milk as one of the key ingredients, it’s not necessary to have milk in a milkshake.

The basic ingredients of a milkshake are ice cream, milk, and flavorings. However, the amount of milk needed in a milkshake can vary depending on personal preference and taste. Milk is typically added to help thin out the ice cream and make the milkshake easier to drink. It also adds a creamy texture and a bit of sweetness.

Some people have lactose intolerance or allergies to milk and cannot have milk in their milkshake. In these instances, non-dairy options such as almond milk, soy milk, or coconut milk can be used as alternatives. These types of milk have a similar consistency to regular milk and can produce a great tasting milkshake.

There are also unique types of milkshake recipes that do not require milk at all. For instance, a fruit smoothie can be considered a type of milkshake, which often consists of fruit, ice, and yogurt. Another popular non-milkshake is the protein shake, which is usually made with protein powder, fruits, and water.

While milk is traditionally considered a key ingredient in a milkshake, it’s not necessary to have milk in a milkshake to make it delicious. The amount of milk used in a milkshake recipe can vary depending on personal preference and dietary requirements. With the advent of non-dairy milk options and various types of milkshake recipes available, anyone can make a great tasting milkshake without using milk.

What is a frosty vs milkshake?

When it comes to frozen treats, there are many options available, with each having its unique texture, consistency and flavor. Two popular types of frozen dessert are milkshakes and Frosties. Although they sound similar, they are quite different.

A milkshake is a dairy-based drink that is made by blending milk, ice cream or other frozen dairy products and flavorings. The primary ingredients used in a shake include milk and ice cream, which are whipped together to form a smooth, creamy texture. Moreover, milkshakes are usually made by blending everything together in a mixer or blender to create a uniform texture. The mixture can be poured into a glass and consumed immediately, or toppings like whipped cream, syrup, and sprinkles can be added on top.

On the other hand, a Frosty is a soft-serve dessert that is sold by the fast-food chain Wendy’s. The consistency and texture are the key differences between a traditional milkshake and a Frosty. According to Wendy’s, the Frosty was designed to be “thick enough to use a spoon, smooth enough to use a straw, and perfect when enjoyed on the end of a fry.” The dessert is made using a blend of dairy products and other ingredients to achieve its unique texture. A Frosty is denser, creamier, and thicker than a milkshake, which means it’s not as likely to spill out of the container or melt quickly.

While a milkshake and Frosty might seem like similar frozen dessert treats, they have several differences that make them unique. A milkshake is a drink that consists of milk, ice cream, and other flavorings, while a Frosty is a frozen dessert that is denser and creamier than a traditional shake. Both are delicious treats that can satisfy your sweet tooth cravings, so the choice ultimately comes down to personal preference.

How much ice cream is in a milkshake?

Milkshakes are a classic American treat that have been enjoyed by people of all ages for many years. The key ingredient in a milkshake is, of course, ice cream – but how much ice cream is really in a milkshake?

The answer to this question can vary depending on a few different factors, such as the recipe used and personal preference. However, as a general rule, a milkshake typically contains around one cup of ice cream.

To make a milkshake at home, a common ratio for ingredients is 1 cup of ice cream to 1/4 cup of milk. This ratio allows the shake to blend smoothly and not be too thick or thin. Of course, if you prefer a thinner or thicker shake, you can adjust this ratio to your liking.

When making a milkshake, it’s important to use good quality ice cream that you enjoy. Whether you opt for a classic vanilla flavor or something more unique like rocky road or mint chocolate chip, the ice cream is what will give your shake its deliciously creamy and sweet flavor.

Once you have your ingredients gathered, making a milkshake is easy. Simply blend the milk and ice cream together in a blender until smooth. You can also add in any additional flavors or mix-ins, such as chocolate syrup or chopped nuts, to customize your shake even further.

The amount of ice cream in a milkshake can vary, but a good starting point is around one cup. So next time you’re looking to satisfy your sweet tooth, whip up a delicious milkshake and enjoy!

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *