Skip to Content

What is the best tool to make a protein shake?

Protein shakes have become an incredibly popular supplement for athletes, bodybuilders, and anyone looking to add more protein to their diet. With so many protein powders and shakers on the market, it can be difficult to determine which is the best tool for making protein shakes.

In this comprehensive guide, we will compare the pros and cons of using a blender versus a shaker bottle for making protein shakes. We will also provide recommendations on specific blenders and shaker bottles to consider based on your needs and budget.

Blenders vs Shaker Bottles for Protein Shakes

The two most common tools used for making protein shakes are blenders and shaker bottles. Here is a comparison of the key differences between using a blender versus a shaker:



  • Allow for mixing of ingredients evenly and smoothly
  • Can incorporate a variety of ingredients like fruits, vegetables, nut butters, etc
  • Create shakes with any texture from thin to thick


  • Require access to power outlet
  • Can be noisy
  • More cleanup required than shaker bottle
  • Not as portable

Shaker Bottles


  • Convenient and portable
  • Easy to use – just add ingredients and shake
  • Minimal cleanup
  • Typically inexpensive


  • Can leave protein powder clumps if not shaken enough
  • Difficult to blend thick ingredients like peanut butter
  • Limited in ingredients – best for protein powder and water/milk

Based on these key factors, blenders provide more versatility and customization for protein shakes, while shaker bottles offer convenience and portability. The right tool will depend on your priorities and protein shake preferences.

Best Blenders for Protein Shakes

If you want to create customized, restaurant-quality protein shakes with varied textures and ingredients, a quality blender is the best tool for the job. Here are our top picks for blenders to whip up excellent protein shakes:

Vitamix 5200

The Vitamix 5200 is a premium professional-grade blender known for making incredibly smooth shakes. With a 2+ peak horsepower motor, aircraft-grade stainless steel blades, and variable speed control, it can blend just about any ingredients easily. The 64-ounce container is ideal for large protein shakes.

NutriBullet Pro

The NutriBullet Pro is a compact yet powerful single-serve blender. The 900-watt motor and stainless steel blades provide smooth nutrient extraction, and it includes multiple cup sizes. It’s great for quickly whipping up a protein shake to take on-the-go.

Ninja Professional Blender

This affordable blender offers professional performance thanks to its powerful 1100-watt motor and Total Crushing blades. With a 72-ounce pitcher, you can make large batches. The Ninja excels at pulverizing ice and frozen fruit for creamy, frosty shakes.

Oster Versa Pro Series

The Oster Versa offers similar performance to higher-end blenders but at a more budget-friendly price point. The 1400-watt motor, reversing blades, and variable speeds handle tough ingredients with ease. It comes with a 64-ounce jar and 20-ounce cup.

No matter which of these excellent blenders you choose, you’ll be able to easily create customized protein shakes to support your fitness goals.

Best Shaker Bottles for Protein Shakes

If convenience and portability are your top priorities for making protein shakes, then a quality shaker bottle is the way to go. Here are some of the best shaker bottles on the market:

BlenderBottle Classic

This is one of the most popular shaker bottles with its patented mixing system – the 316 surgical-grade stainless steel wire whisk inside breaks up powders smoothly. It’s durable, easy to use, dishwasher-safe, and available in a variety of colors and sizes.

Hydro Flask Shake & Go Fitness Bottle

Hydro Flask’s insulated stainless steel bottle keeps shakes cold for hours. The unique mixing cage allows the wire ball to move freely to mix ingredients. The secure flip lid, soft silicone boot, and slip-free powder coating all add convenience.

Ello Syndicate Shaker Bottle

This shaker stands out with its stylish, modern design. The flip cap securely snaps closed, and the removable strainer prevents clumps. It’s made of BPA-free plastic and comes in an array of color combinations.

Iron Flask Sports Water Bottle

The Iron Flask is ideal for taking protein shakes on the go thanks to its durable stainless steel construction, leak-proof lid, and double wall vacuum insulation to maintain temperatures. Bonus points for the included recipe ebook.

With any of these top shaker bottles, you can quickly and easily mix up protein shakes anytime, anywhere.

Additional Considerations When Selecting a Protein Shake Maker

Here are some other factors to keep in mind when choosing the best tool for your protein shake needs:

  • Your budget – Blenders vary widely in price. Select one that fits your budget but don’t sacrifice too much quality.
  • Power – More power means smoother shakes. Look for at least 700 watts for a blender.
  • Capacity – Will you be making shakes only for yourself or for a family? Choose accordingly.
  • Ease of cleaning – Blenders require more cleanup than shakers. See if it’s dishwasher-safe.
  • Noise level – Blenders can be noisy. If you’ll use it early mornings, look for quieter models.
  • Durability – With both blenders and shakers, opt for ones designed to withstand daily use.
  • Special features – Some blenders have pre-programmed settings, timers, travel cups, etc. Decide if you require any extra features.

Taking these factors into consideration will help select the ideal protein shake maker for your lifestyle and needs.

Top Protein Shake Ingredients and Add-Ins

Let’s now take a look at some of the top ingredients you can add to protein shakes using a blender or shaker bottle:

Ingredient Benefits
Milk or milk alternatives Provides creaminess, protein, vitamins
Frozen fruits Thickens shake, adds nutrients and sweentess
Nut butters Healthy fats, flavor, creaminess
Oats Fiber, vitamins, fills you up
Greek yogurt Protein, creaminess, probiotics
Chia seeds Fiber, omega-3s
Flax seeds Fiber, omega-3s
Cinnamon Antioxidants, flavor
Cocoa powder Antioxidants, flavor
Spinach Nutrients, vitamins

The possibilities are endless when using a blender! Try out unique flavor combinations to find your perfect protein shake.

Sample Protein Shake Recipes

Here are a few delicious protein shake recipes to try making with your blender or shaker bottle:

Chocolate Peanut Butter Protein Shake

  • 2 scoops chocolate protein powder
  • 1 cup milk of choice
  • 2 tablespoons peanut butter
  • 1 frozen banana
  • 1 handful ice

Vanilla Berry Protein Shake

  • 2 scoops vanilla protein powder
  • 1 cup low-fat yogurt
  • 1 cup frozen mixed berries
  • 1 tablespoon ground flaxseed

Tropical Green Protein Shake

  • 2 scoops vanilla protein powder
  • 1 cup coconut water
  • 1 cup pineapple chunks
  • 1 cup spinach
  • 1 tablespoon chia seeds

Get creative and come up with your own favorites!


In conclusion, choosing between a blender versus a shaker bottle depends on whether you want to make super customizable shakes or convenient portable shakes. Blenders allow you to include diverse ingredients and textures to optimize your protein shakes. Simple shaker bottles offer portability and ease of use.

Top-rated blenders include Vitamix, NutriBullet, Ninja, and Oster models. Excellent shaker bottle options are BlenderBottle, Hydro Flask, Ello Syndicate, and Iron Flask. Consider your budget, lifestyle, and priorities when selecting the best protein shake maker for you.

With a high-quality blender or shaker, you can whip up healthy, delicious protein shakes using your favorite ingredients. Drink up to recover after workouts, build muscle, lose weight, or simply to add extra protein to your diet.