Are pickles a natural laxative?
Pickles have long been touted as a food that can help relieve constipation. The sour and salty brine that pickles sit in is thought to have natural laxative properties. But is there any truth to the claim that pickles can get things moving? Let’s take a closer look at whether pickles really are a natural laxative.
What Causes Constipation?
Constipation occurs when stool passes through the large intestine too slowly. This slow transit through the colon results in too much water being absorbed from the stool, making it hard and dry. Constipation has many causes, including:
- Low fiber diet
- Dehydration
- Lack of exercise
- Certain medications
- Ignoring the urge to go
- Stress
- Pregnancy
- Travel
- Diseases like diabetes or IBS
When stool moves too slowly through the colon, it becomes difficult to pass and can lead to symptoms like straining, bloating, abdominal pain, and feeling like you can’t completely empty your bowels.
How Can Diet Help Relieve Constipation?
One way to help prevent and relieve constipation is by making dietary changes. Certain foods are more likely to help keep you regular, while others may make constipation worse.
Some foods that can help get things moving include:
- High fiber foods – fiber adds bulk to stool and helps it move more quickly through the colon. Good sources include fruits, vegetables, whole grains, beans, lentils, and nuts.
- Prunes – prunes contain sorbitol, a sugar alcohol with natural laxative effects.
- Fluids – staying hydrated is key, so drink plenty of water, juice, tea, and other non-caffeinated beverages.
- Probiotic foods – probiotics may help restore gut bacteria. Try yogurt, kefir, kombucha, and fermented foods.
- Coffee – the caffeine in coffee can stimulate the colon. But go easy, too much can cause dehydration.
Foods that may worsen constipation and should be limited include:
- Dairy – dairy products can cause bloating and gas.
- Red meat – high-fat meats can slow digestion.
- Processed foods – these tend to be low in fiber.
- Fried & fatty foods – high fat foods take longer to move through the colon.
- Alcohol – alcohol dehydrates the body and slows motility.
Making dietary tweaks like increasing fiber and fluid intake can often help relieve mild constipation. But are pickles one food that lives up to the hype when it comes to getting things moving?
What’s in Pickle Juice?
To understand if pickles can relieve constipation, it helps to look at what’s actually in the brine that pickles sit in.
The main ingredients in pickle juice are:
- Water – provides hydration.
- Vinegar – often distilled white vinegar.
- Salt – table salt or kosher salt.
- Dill – provides flavor.
- Garlic – adds flavor.
- Onion – enhances pickle flavor.
- Spices – like mustard seed, black peppercorns, etc.
Of these ingredients, the main ones thought to have an effect on constipation are:
Vinegar
Vinegar contains acetic acid, which may help increase motility in the colon. The acidic nature of vinegar could enable it to draw water into the colon to soften stool and stimulate contractions.
Salt
Consuming salt causes the body to retain water, so the extra fluid in the colon could help soften stool. However, eating too much salt is linked with increased blood pressure.
Spices
Spices like garlic, dill, mustard, and pepper may trigger intestinal contractions to move stool along. But the evidence on this is limited.
So while some components in pickle juice may provide a laxative effect, is it enough to clinically treat constipation? Let’s look at the evidence.
Research on Pickles for Constipation
Very few studies have looked specifically at pickles as a remedy for constipation. However, some research provides clues:
Studies on vinegar:
- A 2004 study gave 20 constipated patients apple juice with and without added vinegar. The vinegar increased stool frequency and softened stool consistency.
- An older study from the 1990s found vinegar followed by water stimulated motility in the colon.
Studies on garlic:
- Some research indicates garlic extracts may stimulate contractions in the intestine.
- Other studies show garlic powder can act as a laxative by drawing water into the intestines.
Anecdotal evidence:
- Many people report that drinking a brine from a jar of pickles helps relieve bloating and constipation when they feel symptoms.
- The laxative effect is likely from the vinegar, salt and fluid content.
However, no studies have looked specifically at pickle juice as a constipation treatment. More research is needed to prove whether pickles have laxative properties.
Are Pickles a Proven Constipation Remedy?
Based on the limited evidence, can we definitively say that pickles are a natural laxative? Here’s a summary:
| Evidence for Pickles as a Laxative | Evidence Against Pickles as a Laxative |
|---|---|
|
|
While there are some theoretical reasons pickles could alleviate constipation, there’s insufficient evidence to name them a proven natural remedy.
More rigorous clinical studies are needed to demonstrate pickles have laxative effects and are safe as a home treatment. Anecdotal reports aren’t enough to substantiate the claims.
Are Pickles a Good Constipation Remedy?
Pickles may provide very modest relief for mild, occasional constipation. The vinegar and salt content can draw water into the colon to soften stool. And the fluid content helps replace water lost through dehydration.
However, for chronic or severe constipation, pickles should not replace proven treatments. Consulting a doctor to find an effective regimen is important.
Some concerns with relying on pickles as a constipation aid include:
- Very high sodium content – excessive salt intake stresses the cardiovascular system.
- Insufficient fiber – pickles themselves provide no fiber to add bulk to stool.
- Low in nutrients – pickles offer very minimal vitamins, minerals, and antioxidants.
- May aggravate conditions – the high acidity could worsen issues like GERD or ulcers.
Additionally, some other drawbacks are:
- Inconsistent laxative effect – it may provide relief in some instances but not others.
- Poor long-term solution – doesn’t address underlying cause of constipation.
- Can be habit forming – the colon may come to depend on the pickle stimulation.
For occasional constipation, pickles may provide some quick relief in conjunction with other remedies. But they should not be relied on as a primary treatment.
Other Home Remedies for Constipation
While more research is still needed, some natural constipation remedies have more robust evidence behind them than pickles. Some options to try include:
| Remedy | How It Works |
|---|---|
| Prunes | Sorbitol draws water into the colon. Provide fiber. |
| Flaxseed | Adds bulk and softens stool due to mucilage content. |
| Olive oil | Lubricates the colon to help stool pass easier. |
| Exercise | Physical activity stimulates the intestines. |
| Hot drinks | Warm liquids raise body temperature which triggers reflexes in colon. |
| Yogurt | Probiotics promote regularity. Calcium draws in water. |
Focusing on overall diet, hydration, exercise, and lifestyle factors can help prevent constipation in the long-run. Consulting a doctor can also help diagnose any underlying cause.
The Bottom Line
Pickles may offer modest relief for occasional constipation thanks to their salt and vinegar content. But there’s insufficient evidence to name them a proven natural remedy.
While some people report pickles provide a helpful laxative effect, they shouldn’t replace prudent medical care. For chronic issues, see a doctor to find effective treatment and get to the root cause.
Incorporating more fiber, fluids, exercise, and probiotics into your routine can promote regularity. An overall healthy lifestyle is key for optimal digestive health over the long-term.
References:…
